16 players from the AL East division were selected to represent the American League in the 2023 MLB All-Star Game. Two of these selections, Aaron Judge and Shane McClanahan, did not participate due to injuries. Four of these selections were starters of the Midsummer Classic including Randy Arozarena, Austin Hays, Yandy Diaz, and Gerrit Cole.

All of the AL East players selected to the All-Star Game include:

• Aaron Judge- New York Yankees, OF

• Adley Rutschman- Baltimore Orioles, C

• Austin Hays- Baltimore Orioles, OF

• Bo Bichette- Toronto Blue Jays, SS

• Felix Bautista- Baltimore Orioles, RP

• Gerrit Cole- New York Yankees, SP

• Jordan Romano- Toronto Blue Jays, RP

• Kenley Jansen- Boston Red Sox, RP

• Kevin Gausman- Toronto Blue Jays, SP

• Randy Arozarena- Tampa Bay Rays, OF

• Shane McClanahan- Tampa Bay Rays, SP

• Vladimir Guerrero Jr.- Toronto Blue Jays, 1B

• Wander Franco- Tampa Bay Rays, SS

• Whit Merrifield- Toronto Blue Jays, 2B

• Yandy Diaz- Tampa Bay Rays, 1B

• Yennier Cano- Baltimore Orioles, RP

Below is how each AL East representative performed for the American League team:

• Adley Rutschman- 0 for 1, lineout

• Austin Hays- 1 for 2, single

• Bo Bichette- 0 for 1, sac fly

• Randy Arozarena- 1 for 2, single

• Vladimir Guerrero Jr.- 0 for 2, groundout, strikeout

• Wander Franco- 0 for 1, flyout

• Whit Merrifield- 1 for 2, single

• Yandy Diaz- 1 for 2, solo home run

• Felix Bautista- 0.2 IP, 1 hit, 2 earned runs

• Gerrit Cole- 1.0 IP, 0 hits, 0 earned runs

• Jordan Romano- 0.1 IP

• Kenley Jansen- 0.1 IP, 1 strikeout

• Yennier Cano- 1.0 IP, 1 hit, 2 strikeouts, 0 earned runs